What do we mean by Destructive and Non-Destructive Editing?
Destructive Editing
Destructive editing is when you make changes directly to the pixels in your image.
It means that you are limited with the edits you might want to make at a later date. Because the edits were made directly to the pixels in the image, they are "hard-baked" in. Anytime we make destructive edits to an image, we should retain the original, unedited image. We can do this by duplicating a layer and then applying those edits to the duplicated layer.
That might seem great, but if we just want to modify those edits, we can't edit them the same as we could the original - because some of the image information is lost. At the time of making the edits, we can undo any edit, but after the image has been saved and closed, on reopening, you don't have the original image to edit.
You may have a duplicate layer, or the original, unedited image, but you would have to start from the beginning, or accept the limitations of continuing to edit the already-edited image. A duplicate layer will add to the file size.
Non-Destructive Editing
Non-Destructive editing is editing an image, but the changes are not made to the original image. The changes are held in a separate entity, such as Adjustment Layers, Layer Masks, Smart Objects, Smart Filters, Layer Styles.
Non-Destructive editing should be your aim whenever you edit an image. Not only does it preserve the original, but also gives you the maximum flexibility to adjust your edits, without compromising the quality of that editing.
This should be the goal, every time you edit an image.
The main advantages of non-destructive editing is the ability to be able to edit at any time in the future, the original edits, without penalty of loss of quality. But an additional benefit is that it doesn't require the duplicating of layers (to preserve access to the original) and thus, the filesize is not enlarged unnecessarily.
Example of Destructive vs Non-Destructive Editing
I will apply a Levels edit to darken this image, in two different ways; destructively and non-destructively.
Please note that this is not a demonstration of good editing technique. It is purely a demonstration of the differences of editing destructively or non-destructively.
There are two ways to adjust Levels;
- The menu; Image > Adjustments > Levels (destructive)
- Levels Adjustment Layer (non-destructive)
Destructive Editing - Adjust Levels via Menu
From the menu, select: Image > Adjustments > Levels...
That opens the Layers panel.
This shows the Histogram before editing.
The black slider is highlighted in green.
The value of the black slider is highlighted in red.
To darken the image, I have dragged the black slider (green box) to a figure of 75 (red box).
The resulting image is in the next step.
This is the result of the previous step, after dragging the black slider to the right, to darken the image.
Let's now suppose that we darkened the image a bit too much and we would like to move the black slider back a bit to the left.
If we haven't closed the image, we could undo the last step. But if the image has been closed and then reopened, we are not able to do that.
Let's open the Levels panel again from the menu; Image > Adjustments > Levels.
Notice that the Histogram now looks quite different. There is less data and there are gaps in the columns. The first adjustment made direct changed to the pixels in the image and the Histogram now reflects that. Some information in the image has been lost. We cannot move the black slider any further left.
To protect against this, if you edit this way, it's a good idea to do so on a duplicate layer, thus protecting the original. This will double the image size and if you want to change the edit, you will have to discard the duplicate layer, make a new duplicate from the original and edit again. If you edited the original layer, there would be no way back, apart from recovering the original from your back up. You do back up your images, right?
Non - Destructive Editing - Levels Adjustment Layer
At the bottom of the layers panel, click on the Adjustment Layer button (highlighted in red).
From the list, select Levels...
The Levels Adjustment Layer panel looks very similar to the Levels panel from the menu.
There are some differences, but they are not the subject of this tutorial.
Let's make exactly the same edits, moving the black slider to the right, to a position of 75.
This produces exactly the same result. Editing Levels either way will apply the same changes.
The Levels Adjustment Layer contains all the editing, so it is not necessary to duplicate the original layer. The layer thumbnail (pink box) shows that the original image remains unchanged, while the image has been made darker.
You can turn on or off the Adjustment Layer by clicking the "eye" (visibility) icon (red box). If the Adjustment Layer is turned off, you will see the original unedited image.
To make changes, double click the Levels Adjustment Layer thumbnail (green box) and you will see the original histogram, with the current edits, which you can now change.
Note that the Histogram remains undamaged. It is whole, as it was to begin with, showing no image data has been lost, unlike editing destructively via the menu.
Summary of Destructive vs Non-Destructive Editing
Whenever you edit an image, it's always good practice to do so in a way that you can return to the image another day and make changes to the original editing. Perhaps you have a new idea or purpose for the image, or perhaps you've learned new skills.
Editing non-destructively will allow you the flexibility to make changes at any time, without compromising the quality of the editing.
Editing destructively will not allow you to do that. If you still have the original unedited image, you can start again, but what if you spend a lot of time achieving a particular effect?
If you edit raw images in Lightroom, that is done non-destructively. If you edit an image in Photoshop, direct from Lightroom that is also done non-destructively. If you open the original raw image directly into Photoshop, again the editing is done non-destructively. You will then have to save the image in your chosen format. The Photoshop .psd format or the .tif format will preserve all layers, while jpeg will not.
